The Inn’s History
Multiple generations of the Newell family are credited with establishing and managing the Wyoming Inn. Though, back when the foundation was laid in 1838, and for the next several decades, the Inn was more often called the “Village Inn” or “Newell’s Temperance Hotel.” The fact that teams of skilled workmen took two years to complete the structure (evidence of their craftsmanship is still abundant today) and that for decades the Inn prohibited any alcohol on the premises likely explains why it still stands today. Sadly, many similar structures disappeared long ago due to fires, possibly ignited by weary travelers dropping lanterns after one too many libations!
Following many years of successful service to the community as a hotel and event space, in 1923, the Inn was acquired by the Wyoming Hotel Association. This group of concerned citizens was determined to safeguard the Inn’s future given its rich history and strategic location between Rochester and Letchworth State Park. Their unifying motto was “Boost Wyoming,” as they worked to ensure the Inn flourished into the new century as it had in the last. Significantly, the Association oversaw many thoughtful restorations, like restoring the dining room’s large fireplace and wood timbers.
The Wyoming Inn is listed on the National Register of Historic Places as part of the "Wyoming Village Historic District"
Moreover, around this time, famed architect and landscape designer Bryant Flemming took an active role in the Inn’s management. We’re blessed that he cast his eye for detail on every aspect of the Inn’s aesthetic design. Luckily, all his thoughtful renovations and architectural embellishments can still be enjoyed by visitors today, a century later!)
Throughout the second half of the 1900s and early 2000s, the Inn changed hands several times. For several decades it even served as a “rest home” for those yearning to spend their remaining years in the peaceful tranquility that only small-town America can provide. Yet, without exception, each subsequent owner cherished the Inn, giving freely of their time and resources. In this spirit, Sarah and Andy have committed to maintaining the Wyoming Inn’s long-standing role within the community as a point of pride and a central gathering place for locals and tourists alike.
